Below you can view all the homes for sale in the Bay Island subdivision located in Sarasota Florida. Listings in Bay Island are updated daily from data we receive from the Tampa multiple listing service.

To learn more about any of these homes or to receive custom notifications when a new property is listed for sale in Bay Island, give us a call at 813-527-9259.

7 Results

Bay Island Sarasota Florida Homes For Sale

Bay Island For Sale $2,350,000

View 3455 Anglin Dr Sarasota FL
View 3455 Anglin Dr Sarasota FL
View 3455 Anglin Dr Sarasota FL
On Market For 10 Days
  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    3

  • Sq. Ft.

    2558

  • Year Built

    1974

  • $/SqFt

    $919

Enjoy the best of both worlds with this Siesta Key lifestyle! This is a must-see! MLS#A4557968. COLDWELL BANKER REALTY.

Bay Island For Sale $6,750,000

View 3722 Flamingo Ave Sarasota FL
View 3722 Flamingo Ave Sarasota FL
View 3722 Flamingo Ave Sarasota FL
On Market For 152 Days
  • Bedrooms

    5

  • Full Bath(s)

    5

  • Sq. Ft.

    4985

  • Year Built

    2023

  • $/SqFt

    $1,354

Located at the north end of Siesta in highly desirable Bay Island. MLS#A4546740. MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY.

Bay Island For Sale $3,649,000

Reduced By $341,000

View 3532 Flamingo Ave Sarasota FL
View 3532 Flamingo Ave Sarasota FL
View 3532 Flamingo Ave Sarasota FL
On Market For 184 Days
  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    3

  • Sq. Ft.

    3162

  • Year Built

    1950

  • $/SqFt

    $1,154

Conveniently located only minutes from downtown Sarasota, local shopping, St Armands circle, Sarasota Memorial Hospital, and Siesta Key Beach and Siesta Village. MLS#A4543285. EXIT KING REALTY.

Bay Island For Sale $3,800,000

Reduced By $100,000

View 3810 Flamingo Ave Sarasota FL
View 3810 Flamingo Ave Sarasota FL
View 3810 Flamingo Ave Sarasota FL
On Market For 190 Days
  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    3

  • Sq. Ft.

    3960

  • Year Built

    2004

  • $/SqFt

    $960

As a resident of Bay Island you get to enjoy the true community feel of friendly morning walkers, a quick golf cart ride to Siesta Key and enjoy a life of relaxation and casual sophistication with the urbane pleasures of nearby Sarasota at your doorstep. MLS#A4543853. KELLER WILLIAMS ON THE WATER.

Bay Island For Sale $1,900,000

On Market For 246 Days
  • Bedrooms

    5

  • Full Bath(s)

    4

  • Sq. Ft.

    2709

  • Year Built

    1939

  • $/SqFt

    $701

Schedule a showing today and start living the island life you've always dreamed of! MLS#A4537131. MODERN INTERNATIONAL REALTY, L.

Bay Island Pended $1,500,000

On Market For 23 Days
  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    1978

  • Year Built

    1952

  • $/SqFt

    $758

You will not find a better deal in the entirety of the key, so come see this beautiful house perfect for a high end rental or ready to make a home for you and yours to make a lifetime of memories! MLS#A4537134. MODERN INTERNATIONAL REALTY, L.

Bay Island Pended $12,600,000

On Market For 251 Days
  • Bedrooms

    5

  • Full Bath(s)

    4

  • Sq. Ft.

    7487

  • Year Built

  • $/SqFt

    $1,683

Sarasota arts, culture, and urban amenities are just a bridge away. MLS#A4534680. COMPASS FLORIDA LLC.

  • 1

Area Stats

These statistics are updated daily from the My Florida Regional MLS. For further analysis or to obtain statistics not shown below please call EasyStreet Realty at 813-527-9259 and speak with one of our real estate consultants.

EasyStreet

Call to Schedule a Showing

(813) 527-9259

(813) 527-9259